As a coach, I can’t do what management refuses to do.
And yet, that’s sometimes exactly what I’m asked to do.
When an organisation reaches out to me, I always pay close attention to what it really wants to place inside the coaching space.
Behind some requests, there can be an unspoken expectation.
Calling someone to order in the manager’s place.
Delivering difficult messages no one has dared to say.
Paving the way for a decision already made: a dismissal, a promotion that won’t happen.
Supporting a so-called development path whose outcome has already been decided.
Sometimes it’s phrased in very subtle ways.
“He needs to understand that he has to change.”
“We’d like you to help him become aware.”
“She needs to work on her presence before we can consider next steps.”
It isn’t always conscious.
But it’s always telling.
Telling of an organisation’s difficulty in setting a clear managerial frame and owning its decisions.
Of course, coaching can grow out of tension, difficult feedback or a performance issue.
That’s not the problem.
The problem starts when coaching replaces the manager’s voice instead of extending it.
In those cases, coaching becomes an ambiguous space.
A fool’s bargain between three parties.
The organisation that knows more than it says.
The coachee who believes they’re entering a space for development.
And the coach who is implicitly asked to carry a message that isn’t theirs.
Coaching can support a courageous conversation.
It cannot replace it.
So in my first meetings, I ask a lot of questions.
What has this person been told about why they’re being coached?
What messages have already been given?
What happens if nothing changes?
Is there a decision already being considered, or already made?
What belongs to coaching? And what belongs to management?
Sometimes, before we even begin, I ask for certain things to be clarified.
That feedback be given.
That expectations be made explicit.
That possible consequences be named.
And that the scope of the engagement be shared honestly.
I can support someone in working on how they show up.
I cannot become the mouthpiece for a message the organisation hasn’t delivered.
Coaching is not a courier service for management.
And what I refuse, deep down, is the outsourcing of managerial courage.
Everyone needs to take their rightful place.
The manager in their role.
The coach in theirs.
And the coachee in their own responsibility.
Because coaching doesn’t repair managerial silence.
But inevitably, it exposes it.
What about you? Have you ever experienced or witnessed coaching being used to sidestep a conversation no one dared to have?