What makes an excellent individual contributor successful can hold them back once they become a manager.
It isn’t a lack of willingness. It’s an excess of competence.
We promote someone because they’ve mastered their job.
They solve problems fast.
They know how to take things in hand.
They’re reliable, effective, indispensable.
And then we expect them to switch to a completely different register.
They no longer just have to produce results.
They have to enable other people to produce them.
That’s where many get stuck.
When a project goes off track, when a deadline looms, when the work isn’t up to standard…
The manager falls back on what they know how to do.
They take the project back and fix it themselves.
They hand over the solution directly and impose their method.
In the short term, it’s effective.
But they’ve also just taken on managerial debt.
Like technical debt, it saves time immediately.
But the time saved today will have to be paid back tomorrow.
Every time a manager does the work in place of their team…
The work gets done, but the skill isn’t developed.
The problem is solved, but autonomy doesn’t progress.
The urgency is absorbed, but dependence on the manager grows.
The next time, the team member comes back even faster.
The manager takes over even more.
And then one day, they complain that their team doesn’t take initiative.
They have to approve everything. Nothing moves without them.
What they thought was efficiency has become a bottleneck.
Every time they take things back, the manager also sends an implicit message.
“When the stakes are high, it’s no longer really your call.”
“If you don’t move fast enough, I’ll do it for you.”
“My way of doing things is still the right way.”
They think they’re securing the result.
They’re weakening their team’s future ability to produce it.
Moving from individual contributor to manager isn’t just about delegating more.
It’s about accepting that others will be slower at first.
That they’ll learn by making mistakes.
That they’ll use a different method.
That the result won’t be exactly what you would have produced yourself.
And above all, no longer looking for your worth in your own execution.
It’s a shift in identity.
The manager has to stop looking for proof of their worth in what they produce themselves.
They need to look for it in what their team becomes capable of producing.
Doing it for them can save a deadline.
Doing it too often stops the team from growing.
Perhaps the real move into management starts there:
when you accept no longer being indispensable to the execution.