They’re called team leads, team coordinators or point people.
The titles vary. The problem stays the same.
In practice, here’s what these people are asked to do.
Get a team to deliver.
Manage tensions.
Deal with performance issues.
Keep engagement up.
Move the collective forward.
But without deciding on promotions, pay rises or sanctions.
To me, it’s an organisational heresy.
You might think this is just about coordination or matrix management.
But it’s not quite that.
The team is relatively stable.
The role is exercised day to day.
The team lead organises the work, monitors performance, gives feedback.
They keep a collective running over time and answer for what the team produces.
They don’t just facilitate an activity.
They carry out a large part of the management work.
This model can work.
When people are autonomous, expectations are clear, relationships are good.
When the line manager genuinely supports the team lead.
In other words, when everyone cooperates.
But an organisational model shouldn’t be designed only for the times when everything is going well.
The problem shows up when a team member doesn’t deliver.
When they reject the priorities.
When they undermine how the collective works.
When a decision about their performance or career becomes necessary.
The team lead can give feedback, raise the alarm, call them to order, make the case.
But at the end of the process, someone else decides.
They have to answer for the outcome, even though the final decision isn’t theirs.
And that creates major confusion.
For the team member: who is my real manager?
The one who steers my work or the one who decides my career?
For the official manager: how do you make fair decisions when you’re removed from the day-to-day work?
For the team lead: how do you embody lasting authority when everyone knows it stops the moment an important decision has to be made?
It isn’t just uncomfortable for the people involved.
It’s an ambiguity created by the organisation.
Faced with these difficulties, the team lead is asked to develop leadership without authority.
To be more influential, more assertive, more persuasive, more legitimate.
These skills are useful.
But they don’t fix a poorly designed role.
By constantly bringing everything back to how people show up, we end up asking one person to single-handedly make up for a poorly designed role.
Management can be shared.
Running the work can be separated from HR decisions.
But in that case, responsibility must also be clearly shared.
You can’t take away part of someone’s means to act.
And ask them to answer alone for the outcome.