We often confuse niceness with kindness.
They’re not the same thing, and they don’t have the same impact.
Niceness, in an interaction, is often a perception.
I can have a respectful intention.
I can choose my words carefully.
I can try to preserve the relationship.
But if what I say creates discomfort, the other person may not see me as “nice” in that moment.
And that’s where the distinction becomes interesting.
Adam Grant, organisational psychologist at Wharton, applies it to politeness.
He distinguishes between what makes people feel good today and what helps them grow tomorrow.
I want to extend it to niceness.
Because in companies, we often confuse the two.
Being seen as pleasant.
And having a genuinely helpful impact.
They’re not the same thing.
You can be seen as nice by avoiding difficult feedback.
By softening a message.
By letting a behaviour slide.
By protecting short-term comfort.
But if the impact is leaving a team to compensate in silence…
A tension settling in for the long term…
Someone discovering too late what no one ever told them…
Then it isn’t kindness.
It’s avoidance.
Well dressed, admittedly. But avoidance all the same.
This week, after a diagnostic phase with a colleague, we gave difficult feedback to a leadership team.
The idea wasn’t to judge, or to provoke.
Nor was it to say things just for the sake of saying them.
It was to name.
Because what isn’t named keeps acting on the system.
Sometimes, the kindest thing you can do for a collective…
Is to put clear words on what it’s producing without seeing it.
Niceness seeks to be well perceived.
Kindness seeks to be useful.
Niceness is a perception.
Kindness is a responsibility.
It doesn’t seek to hurt.
But it refuses to avoid.
What about you, in your management practice, do you make the distinction?